/machines/1RB0LE_1LC1RD_1LA0RB_1RC1RB_1LF0LC_---0RC/check_proof.py · raw
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 123 124 125 126 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 135 136 137 138 139 140 141 142 143 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 153 154 155 156 157 158 159 160 161 162 163 164 165 166 167 168 169 170 171 172 173 174 175 176 177 178 179 180 181 182 183 184 185 186 187 188 189 190 191 192 193 194 195 196 197 198 199 200 201 202 203 204 205 206 207 208 209 210 211 212 213 214 215 216 217 218 219 220 221 222 223 224 225 226 227 228 229 230 231 232 233 234 235 236 237 238 239 240 241 242 243 244 245 246 247 248 249 250 251 252 253 254 255 256 257 258 259 260 261 262 263 264 265 266 267 268 269 270 271 272 273 274 275 276 277 278 279 280 281 282 283 284 285 286 287 288 289 290 291 | #!/usr/bin/env python3 """Check every rule and claim in proof.md for 1RB0LE_1LC1RD_1LA0RB_1RC1RB_1LF0LC_---0RC. Run from anywhere: python3 -B check_proof.py [--cycles N] [--sft] Checks: shift/wall/junction rules (unknown context), bounces B1-B6, probe P0 on the orbit, NORM (tails normalized: nonempty, ending in 1; P strips trailing 0s), IFACE (fixed 16-round-trip protocol one cell left of the X0|D cut), E' (right-part protocol system reproduces P), CYC, INIT1 (C_1(58, 011 D_0) at 758,939), INIT (C_0(59, D_0) at 784,041), HALT. Independent partial simulator (stdlib only). Cells outside a rule's window are UNKNOWN unless the rule says 0^inf; reading an unknown cell fails the check. So a passing shift rule holds for every context, and induction gives it for every repeat count n. """ import random, re, sys, os, json TM = "1RB0LE_1LC1RD_1LA0RB_1RC1RB_1LF0LC_---0RC" TR = {} for q, part in enumerate(TM.split("_")): for s in (0, 1): t = part[3 * s:3 * s + 3] TR[(q, s)] = None if t[2] == "-" else (int(t[0]), 1 if t[1] == "R" else -1, ord(t[2]) - 65) S = "ABCDEF" HERE = os.path.dirname(os.path.abspath(__file__)) BLK = "1101101101" # bulk block (resting form) R1 = "1011110110" # bulk block after the right sweep G = "11110101" # left-sweep gadget: G <E 0 X = ["110111100110011101100100100111101100100110110111010011", "1001001001100100100100110110110011101100100110110111010", "11011001001100100100100110110110011101100100110110111010", "101110100110110010011101100100100111101100100110110111010", "1101001101100100110011101100100100111101100100110110111010", "11011011001001100110011101100100100111101100100110110111010", "10011100110011101100100100111101100100110110111010"] # junction rules J_k: R1^c B> X_k [011 if k=6] --> R1^(c-m) G <E 0 Y_k (j steps) # (c = context blocks the run needs, m = blocks consumed; Y_k = BLK^(m-1) X_{k+1}, Y_5 = X_6) J = {1: dict(c=1, m=1, Y=X[2]), 2: dict(c=2, m=2, Y=BLK + X[3]), 3: dict(c=1, m=1, Y=X[4]), 4: dict(c=1, m=1, Y=X[5]), 5: dict(c=0, m=0, Y=X[6]), 6: dict(c=1, m=1, Y=X[0])} fails = [] def check(name, ok, info=""): print(("PASS " if ok else "FAIL ") + name + ((" " + info) if info else "")) if not ok: fails.append(name) # ---------------- partial simulator ---------------- def cfg(left, tok, right, lzero=False, rzero=False): """Directed-head config. tok '<X' reads last cell of `left`; 'X>' reads first cell of `right`. lzero/rzero: that side continues as 0^inf (else unknown). Returns (cells dict, head pos, state, lz, rz, lo, hi).""" cells = {} for i, c in enumerate(left): cells[i] = int(c) for i, c in enumerate(right): cells[len(left) + i] = int(c) if tok[0] == "<": st, h = S.index(tok[1]), len(left) - 1 else: st, h = S.index(tok[0]), len(left) return dict(cells=cells, h=h, st=st, lo=0, hi=len(left) + len(right) - 1, lz=lzero, rz=rzero) def read(c, p): if p in c["cells"]: return c["cells"][p] if p < c["lo"] and c["lz"]: return 0 if p > c["hi"] and c["rz"]: return 0 return None def step(c): v = read(c, c["h"]) if v is None: return "UNKNOWN" t = TR[(c["st"], v)] if t is None: return "HALT" w, d, n = t c["cells"][c["h"]] = w; c["h"] += d; c["st"] = n return None def run(c, n): for i in range(n): e = step(c) if e: return e, i return None, n def same(c, t, shift=0): """c equals target t placed `shift` cells to the right (same unknown/zero structure assumed).""" if c["st"] != t["st"] or c["h"] != t["h"] + shift: return False keys = set(c["cells"]) | {k + shift for k in t["cells"]} for k in keys: a = read(c, k) b = t["cells"].get(k - shift, 0 if ((k - shift < t["lo"] and t["lz"]) or (k - shift > t["hi"] and t["rz"])) else None) if a != b: return False return True def rule(name, src, dst, nsteps, shift=0): c = src; err, done = run(c, nsteps) ok = err is None and same(c, dst, shift) check(name, ok, f"{nsteps} steps" if ok else f"err={err} after {done}") return ok def first_left_record(c, cap): lo = c["h"]; n = 0 while n < cap: e = step(c); n += 1 if e: return e, n if c["h"] < lo: return None, n return "CAP", n rng = random.Random(20261010) # ---------------- 1. shift rules and wall rules ---------------- print("== shift and wall rules (unknown context; induction gives all n)") rule("RS B> blk --> R1 B>", cfg("", "B>", BLK), cfg(R1, "B>", ""), 12) rule("LS R1 G <E 0 --> G <E 0 blk", cfg(R1 + G, "<E", "0"), cfg(G, "<E", "0" + BLK), 58) rule("WS 0^inf <A --> 0^inf 1 B>", cfg("0", "<A", "", lzero=True), cfg("1", "B>", "", lzero=True), 1) rule("WE 0^inf 1 G <E 0 --> 0^inf <A blk", cfg("1" + G, "<E", "0", lzero=True), cfg("", "<A", BLK, lzero=True), 29) # (WE target: head on the 0 just left of the old window; blk occupies the old 10-cell window) # ---------------- 2. junction rules J_k (k=1..6) ---------------- print("== junction rules J_k: R1^c B> X_k --> R1^(c-m) G <E 0 Y_k") jsteps = {} for k in range(1, 7): p = J[k]; tail = "011" if k == 6 else "" src = cfg(R1 * p["c"], "B>", X[k] + tail) # find step count by running to the target shape, then re-check exactly probe = cfg(R1 * p["c"], "B>", X[k] + tail); n = 0; got = None tgt = cfg(R1 * (p["c"] - p["m"]) + G, "<E", "0" + p["Y"]) while n < 5000: if same(probe, tgt): got = n; break if step(probe): break n += 1 if got is None: check(f"J{k}", False, "target not reached"); continue jsteps[k] = got rule(f"J{k} R1^{p['c']} B> X{k}{' 011' if k == 6 else ''} --> R1^{p['c'] - p['m']} G <E 0 Y{k}", src, tgt, got) # minimality of context: one block less must read an unknown cell (documents why the domain is a>=c) if p["c"] > 0: c2 = cfg(R1 * (p["c"] - 1), "B>", X[k] + tail); e, _ = run(c2, got) check(f"J{k} needs exactly c={p['c']} context block(s)", e == "UNKNOWN") # ---------------- 3. bounce rules B_k = WS, RS^a, J_k, LS^(a-m), WE ---------------- print("== bounce rules C_k(a,D) --> C_k+1(a',D), checked by full simulation with D UNKNOWN") beta = {k: 1 + jsteps[k] + 29 - 58 * J[k]["m"] for k in jsteps} print(" beta_k = 1 + j_k + 29 - 58 m_k:", beta, " j_k:", jsteps) for k in range(1, 7): if k not in beta: continue p = J[k]; ok_all = True; bad = None avals = list(range(p["c"], p["c"] + 12)) + [rng.randint(20, 200) for _ in range(6)] + [rng.randint(500, 3000) for _ in range(3)] for a in avals: tail = "011" if k == 6 else "" src = cfg("0", "<A", BLK * a + X[k] + tail, lzero=True) a2 = a + (1 if k == 5 else 0); nx = 0 if k == 6 else k + 1 dst = cfg("0", "<A", BLK * a2 + X[nx], lzero=True) # bulk length changes by +-10 at k=5 and the junction length changes: align on the D cut cut_src = 1 + len(BLK * a + X[k] + tail); cut_dst = 1 + len(BLK * a2 + X[nx]) e, n = run(src, 70 * a + beta[k]) if e or not same(src, dst, cut_src - cut_dst): ok_all = False; bad = (a, e); break # and it is the first left record (the bounce ends exactly here) check(f"B{k} C{k}(a,D) --> C{(k + 1) % 7}(a{'+1' if k == 5 else ''},D) in 70a+{beta[k]} steps, a>={p['c']}" + (", D=011D'" if k == 6 else ""), ok_all, f"{len(avals)} values of a up to {max(avals)}" if ok_all else str(bad)) # ---------------- 4. probe rule on orbit tails ---------------- print("== probe P0: R1 B> X0 D --> G <E 0 X1 011 P(D) (only on tails from the orbit; NOT proved for a language)") IFACE = len(R1) + len(X[0]) - 1 # index of the last cell of X0 = cell 0 of the right side def edge(D, cap=10**6, census=None): """Run the junction-level probe on D with 1 context block (R1). Returns (P(D), j0) or (None, reason). D is normalized: empty or ending in 1 (trailing 0s belong to 0^inf); P(D) is returned normalized too. census: optional dict; receives the crossing sequences at the boundary IFACE-1|IFACE (one cell left of the X0|D cut) and at the cut IFACE|IFACE+1, as tuples of ('>' or '<', state after the move).""" c = cfg(R1, "B>", X[0] + D, rzero=True); bi, bc = [], [] for n in range(cap): # target shape: R1^0 G <E 0 X1 011 ... head at index len(G)-1 if c["st"] == 4 and c["h"] == len(G) - 1: w = "".join(str(read(c, i)) for i in range(0, len(G) + 1 + len(X[1]) + 3)) if w == G + "0" + X[1] + "011": hi = max(c["cells"]); r = "".join(str(c["cells"].get(i, 0)) for i in range(len(G) + 1 + len(X[1]) + 3, hi + 1)) if census is not None: census["iface"] = tuple(bi); census["cut"] = tuple(bc) return r.rstrip("0"), n h0 = c["h"]; e = step(c) if e: return None, ("BADJ (left the R1 context block)" if e == "UNKNOWN" else e) if census is not None: h1 = c["h"] for b, lst in ((IFACE, bi), (IFACE + 1, bc)): if h0 == b - 1 and h1 == b: lst.append((">", S[c["st"]])) elif h0 == b and h1 == b - 1: lst.append(("<", S[c["st"]])) return None, "CAP" # The right-side protocol system (proof.md section 6): right side = cells >= IFACE, i.e. "1" D 0^inf. PROTO_IN, PROTO_OUT = "BDCDBDCBDBBBDCCB", "CEACCFAEECECAAAC" def edge_right(D, cap=10**6): """Right side only. Excursion p: head enters cell 0 in state PROTO_IN[p]; it must step left off cell 0 in state PROTO_OUT[p]. After excursion 16, cells 0..3 must read 0011; P(D) = cells 4.. (normalized).""" t = {i: int(ch) for i, ch in enumerate("1" + D)}; n = 0 for p in range(16): h, q = 0, S.index(PROTO_IN[p]) while h >= 0: if n >= cap: return None, "CAP" v = t.get(h, 0); tr = TR[(q, v)] if tr is None: return None, "HALT" t[h] = tr[0]; h += tr[1]; q = tr[2]; n += 1 if S[q] != PROTO_OUT[p]: return None, f"BREAK at excursion {p + 1}" hi = max(t) if "".join(str(t.get(i, 0)) for i in range(4)) != "0011": return None, "BADTAIL" return "".join(str(t.get(i, 0)) for i in range(4, hi + 1)).rstrip("0"), n D0 = open(os.path.join(HERE, "work", "D_cycle0.txt")).read().strip() ncyc = int(sys.argv[sys.argv.index("--cycles") + 1]) if "--cycles" in sys.argv else 3000 D = D0; orbit = [D0]; js = []; okc = True; ifaces = set(); cuts = set() for i in range(ncyc): cen = {} Dn, j = edge(D, census=cen) if Dn is None: okc = False; print(" cycle", i, "->", j); break js.append(j); D = Dn; orbit.append(D); ifaces.add(cen["iface"]); cuts.add(cen["cut"]) check(f"P0 orbit of the edge map from D_0: {len(orbit) - 1} cycles, junction intact, no halt", okc, f"|D| in [{min(map(len, orbit))},{max(map(len, orbit))}], j0 in [{min(js)},{max(js)}]") check("NORM every orbit tail D_n is normalized (nonempty, ends in 1); |D_n| + 3n = 21 (mod 30)", all(d and d[-1] == "1" and (len(d) + 3 * n) % 30 == 21 for n, d in enumerate(orbit))) proto = tuple(x for a, b in zip(PROTO_IN, PROTO_OUT) for x in ((">", a), ("<", b))) check(f"IFACE crossing sequence one cell left of the X0|D cut: identical in all {len(orbit) - 1} cycles, " f"32 crossings = 16 round trips = (in,out) {list(zip(PROTO_IN, PROTO_OUT))}", ifaces == {proto}) print(f" (info) at the X0|D cut itself: {len(cuts)} distinct crossing sequences, lengths {sorted({len(c) for c in cuts})}") nr = min(len(orbit) - 1, 500); ok_r = all(edge_right(orbit[i])[0] == orbit[i + 1] for i in range(nr)) check(f"E' right-side protocol system reproduces P on the first {nr} orbit tails", ok_r) cmpf = os.path.join(HERE, "work", "D_edgemap_1951.txt") if os.path.exists(cmpf) and len(orbit) > 1951: check("P0 edge-map orbit at cycle 1951 == work/D_edgemap_1951.txt (scripts/edgemap.c)", orbit[1951] == open(cmpf).read().strip()) c2 = cfg("", "B>", X[0] + D0, rzero=True); e, _ = run(c2, js[0]) check("P0 needs the R1 context block (reads left of X0)", e == "UNKNOWN") # whole-bounce probe: C0(a,D) --> C1(a, 011 P(D)) in 70a + 1 + j0 + 29 - 58 steps, random a, sampled orbit tails ok_all = True; bad = None for t in range(25): i = rng.randrange(len(orbit) - 1); D, Dn = orbit[i], orbit[i + 1]; a = rng.choice([1, 2, 3, rng.randint(4, 60), rng.randint(100, 800)]) src = cfg("0", "<A", BLK * a + X[0] + D, lzero=True, rzero=True) dst = cfg("0", "<A", BLK * a + X[1] + "011" + Dn, lzero=True, rzero=True) n = 70 * a + 1 + js[i] + 29 - 58 e, _ = run(src, n) if e or not same(src, dst, src["h"] - dst["h"]): # both ends 0^inf: compare up to translation ok_all = False; bad = (i, a, e); break check("P0 C0(a,D) --> C1(a,011 P(D)) in 70a+j0(D)-28 steps (25 random (a, orbit D), a>=1)", ok_all, "" if ok_all else str(bad)) # ---------------- 5. cycle law and initial segment ---------------- print("== cycle law and initial segment") SB = sum(beta.values()) ok_all = True for t in range(6): i = rng.randrange(len(orbit) - 1); a = rng.randint(1, 40) src = cfg("0", "<A", BLK * a + X[0] + orbit[i], lzero=True, rzero=True) dst = cfg("0", "<A", BLK * (a + 1) + X[0] + orbit[i + 1], lzero=True, rzero=True) n = 490 * a + 70 + SB + js[i] - 28 e, _ = run(src, n) if e or not same(src, dst, src["h"] - dst["h"]): ok_all = False; break check(f"CYC C0(a,D) --> C0(a+1,P(D)) in 490a+{70 + SB - 28}+j0(D) steps (6 random)", ok_all) c = cfg("", "A>", "", lzero=True, rzero=True) N0, N1 = 784041, 758939 e, _ = run(c, N1) lo = min(k for k, v in c["cells"].items() if v) ; hi = max(k for k, v in c["cells"].items() if v) tape = "".join(str(c["cells"].get(i, 0)) for i in range(lo, hi + 1)) check(f"INIT1 0^inf A> 0^inf --({N1})--> C1(58, 011 D_0) (earliest entry into the family with full X_k words)", e is None and c["st"] == 0 and c["h"] == lo - 1 and tape == BLK * 58 + X[1] + "011" + D0) e, _ = run(c, N0 - N1) lo = min(k for k, v in c["cells"].items() if v) ; hi = max(k for k, v in c["cells"].items() if v) tape = "".join(str(c["cells"].get(i, 0)) for i in range(lo, hi + 1)) init_ok = (e is None and c["st"] == 0 and c["h"] == lo - 1 and tape == BLK * 59 + X[0] + D0) check(f"INIT 0^inf A> 0^inf --({N0})--> C0(59, D_0) = 0^inf <A blk^59 X0 D_0 0^inf, |D_0|={len(D0)}", init_ok) # ---------------- 6. halting transition ---------------- into_F = [(S[q] + str(s)) for (q, s), t in TR.items() if t and t[2] == 5] check("HALT only F0 is undefined; F is entered only by E0 (1LF)", into_F == ["E0"] and [k for k, t in TR.items() if t is None] == [(5, 0)]) # ---------------- 7. optional: SFT_k closure falsification ---------------- if "--sft" in sys.argv: print("== SFT_k test: random D whose k-factors all occur on the orbit; one probe") for k in (8, 12, 16): Sk = set(); P = set() for D in orbit: w = D + "0" * k Sk.update(w[j:j + k] for j in range(len(w) - k + 1)); P.add(D[:k - 1]) ext = {} for f in Sk: ext.setdefault(f[:-1], []).append(f[-1]) st = {"ok": 0, "break": 0, "escape": 0}; Pl = sorted(P); tries = 0 while sum(st.values()) < 200 and tries < 10000: tries += 1; w = rng.choice(Pl) while not w.endswith("000") and len(w) < 600: ch = ext.get(w[-(k - 1):]) if not ch: w = None; break w += rng.choice(ch) if w is None or len(w) >= 600 or len(w) < 120: continue Dn, j = edge(w.rstrip("0")) if Dn is None: st["break"] += 1; continue ww = Dn + "0" * k if any(ww[i:i + k] not in Sk for i in range(len(ww) - k + 1)): st["escape"] += 1 else: st["ok"] += 1 print(f" k={k}: {len(Sk)} factors; {st}") print("\nSUMMARY:", "ALL PASS" if not fails else f"{len(fails)} FAIL: {fails}") sys.exit(1 if fails else 0) |