/machines/1RB0LC_0RC0RB_1LD0RE_0LE0LF_1LA0LB_1RA---/check_twin.py · raw
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 123 124 125 126 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 135 136 137 138 139 140 141 142 143 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 153 154 155 156 157 158 159 160 161 162 163 164 165 166 167 168 169 170 171 172 173 174 175 176 177 178 179 180 181 182 183 184 185 186 187 188 189 190 191 192 193 194 195 196 197 198 199 200 201 202 203 204 205 206 207 208 209 210 211 212 213 214 215 216 217 218 219 220 221 222 223 224 225 226 227 228 229 230 231 232 233 234 235 236 237 238 239 240 241 242 243 244 245 246 247 248 249 250 251 252 253 254 255 256 257 258 259 260 261 262 263 264 265 266 267 268 269 270 271 272 273 274 275 276 277 278 279 280 281 282 283 284 285 286 287 288 289 290 291 292 293 294 295 296 297 298 299 300 301 302 303 304 305 306 307 308 309 310 311 312 313 314 315 316 317 318 319 320 321 322 323 324 325 326 327 328 329 330 331 332 333 334 335 336 | #!/usr/bin/env python3 """check_twin.py: checks the twin-port analysis of 740 line 64 (P-64) against busycoq's Sk1like_TC_v1.v Module TM1. Result: the port is REFUTED. This script checks every fact the refutation in notes.md rests on. 64 = 1RB0LC_0RC0RB_1LD0RE_0LE0LF_1LA0LB_1RA--- TM1 = 1LB0RC_0LC0LB_1RD0LE_0RE1RF_1RA0RB_1RA--- (upstream, proved nonhalting) 64f = flip(64) = 1LB0RC_0LC0LB_1RD0LE_0RE0RF_1RA0RB_1LA--- (TM1's frame: same state names) Sections (each prints PASS/FAIL; SUMMARY is PASS only if all pass): M relation: byte-exact holdout line 64; flip(64) differs from TM1 in exactly D1 and F0; line 124 is the same table renamed (TM3's renaming) and started in TM1's C. C every case of RInc_spec / Inc_spec re-derived symbolically (busycoq `es` style: concrete steps, shift rules with a travelling context, the IH at the abstract tail): TM1's map on TM1: all 42 obligations; 64f: the 39 cases where TM1 never fires D1 derive unchanged, the 3 exit cases (the only ones that fire D1) do NOT; the twin map RIncF (3 changed exits + Tp3 = [0;1;1;0;0;1] + its 2 callers) derives on 64f: all 44 obligations. I init: both machines reach toC x0 = (1, D0011 14 (D0011 5 D001T)) at step 1699, no D1 before. R the concrete maps (TM1: RInc/Inc; 64f: RIncF/IncF) agree with direct TM simulation on random states (every exit case hit). S step anchoring: line 64 itself (unflipped) from the blank tape to 6.5e6 steps: its F entries (39,734 / 841,213 / 6,436,652) fall in Inc steps 109 / 607 / 1746 of IncF. D the divergence: from x0, the two abstract orbits give equal tapes except a 3-cell window after each of the first 6 exits and reconverge after exits 1-5; after exit 6 (Inc 528,713) they never reconverge: at Inc 529,337 TM1 makes D0011101 (its 7th exit fires at Inc 529,462) while 64f merges the region into one w-block (374,704 cells differ). TM1 reaches the cycle state S' at Inc 1,333,817; 64f does not. The four critical Inc steps are re-run directly on the list strings (line 64 and the mirror of TM1). T line 124 against TM3 (informational, same table): the same divergence, 15 Inc steps later. N negative controls: wrong twin maps must fail C and R. Usage: python3 -B check_twin.py [--quick] (about 1-2 minutes; --quick skips S and shortens R) """ import os, sys, random, time HERE = os.path.dirname(os.path.abspath(__file__)) sys.path.insert(0, HERE) sys.setrecursionlimit(10000) import symexec as S ROOT = os.path.dirname(os.path.dirname(HERE)) L64 = '1RB0LC_0RC0RB_1LD0RE_0LE0LF_1LA0LB_1RA---' L124 = '1RB0LC_0RC0RF_1RD0RE_1LE0RA_0LA0LE_1LD---' TM1 = '1LB0RC_0LC0LB_1RD0LE_0RE1RF_1RA0RB_1RA---' TM3 = '1RB0LC_0RC1RF_1RD0RE_1LE0RA_0LA0LE_1RD---' T64F = S.flip_str(L64) QUICK = '--quick' in sys.argv results = [] def report(sec, ok, msg): results.append((sec, ok)) print('%s %s %s' % (sec, 'PASS' if ok else 'FAIL', msg), flush=True) # ------------------------------------------------------------------ M def sec_M(): lines = open(os.path.join(ROOT, 'data/holdouts/BB6_holdouts_740.txt')).read().split('\n') report('M', lines[63] == L64, 'holdout line 64 is byte-exact %s' % L64) a, b = S.parse_tm(T64F), S.parse_tm(TM1) diff = sorted(k for k in a if a[k] != b[k]) report('M', T64F == '1LB0RC_0LC0LB_1RD0LE_0RE0RF_1RA0RB_1LA---' and diff == [('D', 1), ('F', 0)], 'flip(64) = %s differs from TM1 exactly at %s: D1 %s vs %s, F0 %s vs %s' % (T64F, diff, a[('D', 1)], b[('D', 1)], a[('F', 0)], b[('F', 0)])) phi = {'A': 'D', 'B': 'E', 'C': 'A', 'D': 'B', 'E': 'C', 'F': 'F'} # TM1 state -> TM3 state def ren(tab): return {(phi[q], r): (None if t is None else (t[0], t[1], phi[t[2]])) for (q, r), t in tab.items()} ok = ren(S.parse_tm(TM1)) == S.parse_tm(TM3) and ren(S.parse_tm(T64F)) == S.parse_tm(L124) \ and lines[123] == L124 report('M', ok, 'TM3 = TM1 renamed (A,B,C,D,E,F -> D,E,A,B,C,F) and line 124 = 64f renamed the same way: ' 'one table, started in TM1-state A (64) and C (124)') # ------------------------------------------------------------------ C def derive(tmstr, twin): tab = S.parse_tm(tmstr); out = {} for lab, x, ih in S.rinc_cases(twin) + S.inc_cases(twin): if lab.startswith('Inc'): st, run, exp = S.run_inc_case(tab, x, ih, twin) else: st, run, exp = S.run_rinc_case(tab, x, ih, twin) d1 = sum(1 for t in run.trans if t == ('D', 1)) if run else 0 out[lab] = (st.split(':')[0], d1, run) return out EXITS = ['D00101 n=0, r=D00101 n0=1+c0', 'D01 n=1+c', 'D0011101 n=1+c'] def sec_C(): t1 = derive(TM1, False) ok1 = [k for k, v in t1.items() if v[0] == 'ok'] d1 = sorted(k for k, v in t1.items() if v[1]) report('C', len(ok1) == 42 and all(v[0] in ('ok', 'skip') for v in t1.values()) and d1 == sorted(EXITS), "TM1's map on TM1: %d/%d obligations derive (%d inr cases need none); D1 fires only in %s" % (len(ok1), len(ok1), sum(v[0] == 'skip' for v in t1.values()), d1)) tf = derive(T64F, False) same = sorted(k for k, v in tf.items() if v[0] == 'ok') bad = sorted(k for k, v in tf.items() if v[0] not in ('ok', 'skip')) report('C', len(same) == 39 and bad == sorted(EXITS), "TM1's map on 64f: %d obligations derive unchanged; the exit cases fail: %s" % (len(same), bad)) tw = derive(T64F, True) okw = [k for k, v in tw.items() if v[0] == 'ok'] report('C', len(okw) == 44 and all(v[0] in ('ok', 'skip') for v in tw.values()), 'twin map RIncF on 64f: %d/%d obligations derive (new: Tp3 from D01, D00111|Tp3, Inc|Tp3)' % (len(okw), len(okw))) for k in EXITS: r1 = t1[k][2]; rf = tw[k][2] print(' %-30s TM1: %s %s (%s steps)' % (k, r1.end[1], S.fmt(r1.end[2]), r1.steps)) print(' %-30s 64f: %s %s (%s steps)' % ('', rf.end[1], S.fmt(rf.end[2]), rf.steps)) # ------------------------------------------------------------------ I def sec_I(): W = list(S.W) tgt = W + [0, 0, 1, 1] + W * 14 + [0, 0, 1, 1] + W * 5 + [0, 0, 1] res = [] for s in (TM1, T64F): tab = S.parse_tm(s); tape = {}; pos = 0; q = 'A'; steps = 0; d1 = 0; found = None while steps < 5000: if q == 'C': nz = [p for p, v in tape.items() if v] if nz and min(nz) >= pos: seg = [tape.get(p, 0) for p in range(pos, max(max(nz) + 1, pos + len(tgt)))] if seg[:len(tgt)] == tgt and not any(seg[len(tgt):]): found = steps; break r = tape.get(pos, 0); t = tab[(q, r)] if (q, r) == ('D', 1): d1 += 1 tape[pos] = t[0]; pos += 1 if t[1] == 'R' else -1; q = t[2]; steps += 1 res.append((found, d1)) report('I', res == [(1699, 0), (1699, 0)], 'toC x0 reached at step %s (TM1) and %s (64f); D1 firings before: %s, %s' % (res[0][0], res[1][0], res[0][1], res[1][1])) # ------------------------------------------------------------------ R W4 = [0, 0, 0, 1] def tape_of(x): n, st = x out = W4 * n for d in st[::-1]: out += [0, 0, 1] if d == 'T' else S.RD[d[0]] + W4 * d[1] return out def run_to(tab, start, target, cap=200000): tape = {i: v for i, v in enumerate(start)}; pos = 0; q = 'C'; steps = 0; tl = len(target) while steps < cap: r = tape.get(pos, 0); t = tab[(q, r)] if t is None: return 'halt' tape[pos] = t[0]; pos += 1 if t[1] == 'R' else -1; q = t[2]; steps += 1 if q == 'C' and all(v == 0 or p >= pos for p, v in tape.items()): if [tape.get(p, 0) for p in range(pos, pos + tl)] == target and \ all(v == 0 or p < pos + tl for p, v in tape.items()): return 'ok' return 'cap' def model_check(tmstr, twin, n, seed, inc=None): inc = inc or S.inc_c random.seed(seed); tab = S.parse_tm(tmstr); names = list(S.RD) ok = bad = 0; hits = {} for _ in range(n): st = ['T'] + [(random.choice(names), random.choice([0, 0, 1, 1, 2, 3, 5])) for _ in range(random.randint(1, 5))] x = [random.choice([0, 1, 1, 2, 3]), st]; x2 = [x[0], list(st)]; stats = {} try: inc(x2, twin, stats) except (S.Inr, S.TouchedTail): continue for k in stats: if k.startswith('EXIT') or '<-' in k: hits[k] = hits.get(k, 0) + 1 if run_to(tab, tape_of(x), tape_of(x2)) == 'ok': ok += 1 else: bad += 1 return ok, bad, hits def sec_R(): n = 600 if QUICK else 2500 for name, s, twin in (('TM1 map / TM1', TM1, False), ('RIncF / 64f', T64F, True)): ok, bad, hits = model_check(s, twin, n, 7) need = {'EXIT:D01', 'EXIT:D0011101'} | ({'Inc<-Tp3', 'D00111<-Tp3'} if twin else set()) report('R', bad == 0 and ok > 0 and need <= set(hits), '%s: %d/%d random Inc steps match direct simulation; exit-case hits %s' % (name, ok, ok + bad, hits)) # ------------------------------------------------------------------ S def sec_S(): """Run line 64 itself (unflipped, mirror frame) from the blank tape; follow IncF's orbit by matching each predicted toC(x_k) (mirrored) when the machine is in C with nothing to its right.""" tab = S.parse_tm(L64) trans = {k: (t[0], 1 if t[1] == 'R' else -1, t[2]) for k, t in tab.items() if t} x = S.x0_c(); targets = [] for k in range(1800): X = tape_of(x); targets.append((bytes(X[::-1]), sum(X))) S.inc_c(x, True) N = 6500000; size = 60000; off = 50000 tp = bytearray(size); h = off; q = 'A'; hi = off; ones = 0 idx = 0; fent = []; at = {} for step in range(1, N + 1): r = tp[h]; w, d, nq = trans[(q, r)] ones += w - r; tp[h] = w if w and h > hi: hi = h h += d; q = nq if q == 'F': fent.append((step, idx)) if q == 'C' and tp.find(1, h + 1, max(hi + 1, h + 1)) < 0: tgt, n1 = targets[idx] if n1 == ones and bytes(tp[h - len(tgt) + 1:h + 1]) == tgt: at[idx] = step; idx += 1 want = [(39734, 109), (841213, 607), (6436652, 1746)] # x_0..x_{k-1} matched: inside Inc step k report('S', fent == want and at.get(0) == 1699, 'line 64 (unflipped) from blank: x0 at step %s; F entries (step, toC(x_k) states matched so far) %s, ' 'so they fall in Inc steps %s of IncF (exits 1-3 of D); %d orbit states matched to 6.5e6 steps' % (at.get(0), fent, [k for _, k in fent], idx)) # ------------------------------------------------------------------ D def tape_str(x): n, st = x return '0001' * n + ''.join('001' if d == 'T' else ''.join(map(str, S.RD[d[0]])) + '0001' * d[1] for d in st[::-1]) def ndiff(ta, tb): if len(ta) != len(tb): return -1 if ta == tb: return 0 c = 0; i = 0; L = len(ta); stp = 4096 while i < L: if ta[i:i + stp] != tb[i:i + stp]: c += sum(1 for j in range(i, min(L, i + stp)) if ta[j] != tb[j]) i += stp return c def orbit_compare(x0, steps, label): a = [x0[0], list(x0[1])]; b = [x0[0], list(x0[1])] exa, exb, events = [], [], [] active = False; prevd = 0; diverged = None; before = None for k in range(1, steps + 1): pa = [a[0], list(a[1])] if active else None sa, sb = {}, {} S.inc_c(a, False, sa); S.inc_c(b, True, sb) ea = any(x.startswith('EXIT') for x in sa); eb = any(x.startswith('EXIT') for x in sb) if ea: exa.append(k) if eb: exb.append(k) if diverged is None and (ea or eb or active): d = ndiff(tape_str(a), tape_str(b)) if d != prevd: events.append((k, d)) if d > 16 or d < 0: diverged = (k, d, pa, [a[0], list(a[1])], [b[0], list(b[1])]) active = d != 0 prevd = d return a, b, exa, exb, events, diverged S_PAT = [('D0011', 33), ('D00001', 416889), ('D00001', 0), ('D0000101', 31217)] def is_Sprime(x): return x[0] == 1 and [d for d in x[1][::-1][:4]] == S_PAT def sec_D(): t0 = time.time() a, b, exa, exb, events, dv = orbit_compare(S.x0_c(), 1333817, '64') re_ok = [e for e in events if e[0] < 528713] pairs = [(re_ok[i][0], re_ok[i + 1][0]) for i in range(0, len(re_ok) - 1, 2)] ok = (exa[:6] == exb[:6] == [109, 607, 1746, 207707, 370719, 528713] and len(pairs) == 5 and all(e[1] in (3, 0) for e in re_ok) and dv is not None and dv[0] == 529337 and dv[1] == 374704 and 529462 in exa and 529462 not in exb) report('D', ok, 'exits 1-6 at Inc %s in both; 3-cell defect windows %s each close again (diff 0); ' 'first macroscopic divergence at Inc %s (%s differing cells); TM1 exit 7 at Inc 529462 has no twin ' 'counterpart (twin exits: %s)' % (exa[:6], pairs, dv[0] if dv else None, dv[1] if dv else None, exb)) if dv: print(' before Inc %d TM1: %s' % (dv[0], S.fmt_c(dv[2], 8))) print(' after TM1: %s' % S.fmt_c(dv[3], 8)) print(' after 64f: %s' % S.fmt_c(dv[4], 8)) report('D', is_Sprime(a) and not is_Sprime(b) and len(exa) == 38 and len(exb) == 9, "after Inc_Sn 1333816 (1,333,817 Inc steps): TM1 is S' = %s (the upstream proof's cycle state); " '64f is %s; exits so far: TM1 %d, 64f %d (%.0fs)' % (S.fmt_c(a, 4), S.fmt_c(b, 4), len(exa), len(exb), time.time() - t0)) # direct TM-level re-run of the critical Inc steps on the actual list strings sys.path.insert(0, HERE) TM1M = S.flip_str(TM1) allok = True; lines = [] for twin, tmstr, name in ((True, L64, 'line 64'), (False, TM1M, 'mirror(TM1)')): x = S.x0_c(); k = 0 for target in (109, 528713, 529337, 529462): while k < target - 1: S.inc_c(x, twin); k += 1 xb = [x[0], list(x[1])]; st = {} S.inc_c(x, twin, st); k += 1 res, nsteps, fe = tm_inc(tmstr, xb, x) ex = any(s.startswith('EXIT') for s in st) allok &= res == 'ok' and (fe > 0) == ex lines.append('%s Inc %d: %s in %d steps, F entries %d, model exit %s' % (name, k, res, nsteps, fe, ex)) report('D', allok, 'critical Inc steps re-run on the list strings (mirror frame): ' + '; '.join(lines)) def tm_inc(tmstr, x, xn, cap=10 ** 8): tab = S.parse_tm(tmstr) trans = {k: ((t[0], 1 if t[1] == 'R' else -1, t[2]) if t else None) for k, t in tab.items()} X = tape_of(x); Xn = tape_of(xn); M = 64 size = len(X) + 2 * M + 16; tp = bytearray(size); h0 = len(X) - 1 + M for i, v in enumerate(X): tp[h0 - i] = v h = h0; q = 'C'; steps = 0; fe = 0; tgt = bytes(Xn[::-1]); ones = sum(Xn) while steps < cap: t = trans[(q, tp[h])] if t is None: return 'HALT', steps, fe tp[h] = t[0]; h += t[1]; q = t[2]; steps += 1 if q == 'F': fe += 1 if q == 'C' and h >= h0 - 12: lo = h - len(Xn) + 1 if lo >= 0 and bytes(tp[lo:h + 1]) == tgt and sum(tp) == ones: return 'ok', steps, fe if h <= 0 or h >= size - 1: return 'offtape', steps, fe return 'cap', steps, fe # ------------------------------------------------------------------ T def sec_T(): a, b, exa, exb, events, dv = orbit_compare([1, ['T', ('D0011', 15)]], 600000, '124') report('T', dv is not None and dv[0] == 529352 and exa[:6] == exb[:6] and exa[6] == 529477 and 529477 not in exb, 'INFORMATIONAL (line 124 vs TM3, x0 = (1, D0011 15 D001T)): exits 1-6 at Inc %s in both; ' 'divergence at Inc %s (%s cells); TM3 exit 7 at Inc %s missing in 124' % (exa[:6], dv[0] if dv else None, dv[1] if dv else None, exa[6])) # ------------------------------------------------------------------ N def sec_N(): # (1) a wrong twin map: keep the TM1 exit digit D0000101 in the D0011101 exit orig = S.rinc_c def wrong(st, twin, stats=None, depth=0): top = st[-1] if twin and isinstance(top, tuple) and top[0] == 'D0011101' and top[1] > 0: st[-1] = ('D0000101', top[1] - 1); return 0, 2 return orig(st, twin, stats, depth) S.rinc_c = wrong try: ok, bad, _ = model_check(T64F, True, 300, 11, inc=S.inc_c) finally: S.rinc_c = orig report('N', bad > 0, 'wrong twin map (D0011101 exit -> D0000101) is caught by R: %d mismatches' % bad) # (2) TM1's derivation applied to the twin's table must fail the exit cases (already C), and # the twin map applied to TM1's table must fail them too tw_on_tm1 = derive(TM1, True) bad2 = sorted(k for k, v in tw_on_tm1.items() if v[0] not in ('ok', 'skip')) report('N', bad2 == sorted(EXITS), 'twin map on TM1 fails exactly the exit cases: %s' % bad2) # (3) a sabotaged executor table (F0 = 1RA on 64f, i.e. TM1's F0 with 64's D1) must fail C sab = T64F[:-6] + '1RA---' sb = derive(sab, True) bad3 = sorted(k for k, v in sb.items() if v[0] not in ('ok', 'skip')) report('N', len(bad3) > 0, 'sabotaged table %s fails %d twin-map obligations' % (sab, len(bad3))) if __name__ == '__main__': t0 = time.time() sec_M(); sec_C(); sec_I(); sec_R() if not QUICK: sec_S() sec_D(); sec_T(); sec_N() allok = all(ok for _, ok in results) print('SUMMARY: %s (%d checks; verdict: twin port of Sk1like_TC_v1 TM1 REFUTED for line 64; %.0fs)' % ('PASS' if allok else 'FAIL', len(results), time.time() - t0)) |